Mutual Fund & ETFs
Comparing active funds and passive ETFs on evidence
Learn how to judge mutual funds against low-cost index ETFs using rolling returns, expense drag, tracking error, and portfolio overlap. These are evaluation methods, not return forecasts or buy recommendations.
Comparative reviews
Three lenses for pooled investments
Equity mutual funds
Peer grouping compares rolling returns across equal time windows, then checks expense drag and downside capture against the category average.
Hybrid portfolios
Balanced schemes are reviewed on how much equity and debt exposure they hold, how volatility is shared, and whether the mandate stays consistent.
Index and thematic ETFs
Passive products are judged on tracking error, liquidity of the units, and how closely the holdings follow the stated index or theme.
Checkpoints
Four checks before comparing any fund
Manager tenure shows whether results come from a stable team. Standard deviation indicates how much returns have varied. Tracking error measures how far an ETF drifts from its index. Total expense ratio shows the annual cost drag that compounds over time.
These figures are historical and do not guarantee future performance. Verify current data on the fund house or exchange disclosure before deciding.